|
What
are Performance Problems?
Performance problems are glitches or errors in
ongoing situations that need to be corrected. These
occur when things were fine but now they are not,
possibly indicated by a dip in sales or an increase
in customer complaints. Perhaps the problem is
mandated training that doesn't make a dent in
performance, or existing processes or programs that
don't do what they are supposed to do. You'll
know you're dealing with performance problems when
you hear phrases like,
"Do what
it takes to get those sales numbers back where
they were."
"I reviewed the
order fulfillment numbers and they don't come
close to my goals. What can we do?"
"Last year we
revised the appraisal forms. The year before we
brought folks in and asked their opinions. This
year, I know you've been doing some classes for
supervisors. But still the appraisals are best
characterized as perfunctory, when they get them
in on time. What are we going to do?"
Strategies
for handling performance problems
When the organization is confronting a
performance problem, the sponsor is often upset,
worried, annoyed. This is an itch that won't go
away. You may have to deal with the client's
impatience. Remember, this isn't the first time
that the organization, perhaps even your unit, has
taken a whack at this issue.
When you confront a performance problem, you
have two concerns
1. Find out where the "pain" is, then
2. Identify the cause(s) of the problem, from
the vantagepoint of several sources.
Imagine that a company has a been doing
performance appraisals for years, but they have
never been done correctly. It's not good enough to
make a general inquiry about the appraisals. You
need to know if problem is in the appraisal
meetings or documentation. And if it's the
documentation or appraisal report, let's say, then
you want to know which lines are OK and which are
flawed. Then you can seek the causes associated
with the particular problems.
Strategy Table
Here's an abbreviated example. Let's presume
that the request was for help in improving safety
in a manufacturing setting, given some problems at
the plants. At the close of the table, you can ask
why Allison Rossett made these recommendations.
Again, remember please, you must alter this
template to match your unique circumstances.
|
Stages
|
Sources
|
Possible
Questions
|
|
One
|
Customer/sponsor
|
Why do you want to focus on safety
now?
Why hasnt the problem been solved
already?
I looked at our current safety program and
wonder what your thoughts are about
it?
What are our strengths and weaknesses in
this area now?
Where in our organization are the details
related to current safe and unsafe
situations and actions?
|
|
Two
|
Regulatory
reports
|
Review documents for answers to the
following:
What are we doing right?
Wrong?
What did outside evaluators pinpoint?
What did they recommendations?
Where are the most grievous errors or
problems?
|
|
Three
|
Accident reports, insurance claims,
employee complaints
|
Review the documents for answers to the
following: What are our problems?
Where are employees getting hurt?
What are the patterns?
What situations and actions are
unsafe?
|
|
Four
|
Job
incumbents
|
What is causing the major problems
identified in stages 1-3?
Why are employees having these
problems?
If you were king or queen, how would you
solve each of them?
|
|
Five
|
The literature
|
What does the literature say about the
most typical barriers to success in these
areas?
Recommendations?
|
|
Six
|
Supervisors
|
Ive shared the major problem areas
with you, based on my review of reports
and claims.
Do they match your perceptions?
Why does the organization have each of
these problems?
What are the causes?
What can the organization do?
If you ruled the organization, what would
you do?
How might the organization raise safety as
a priority?
Is it one of your priorities?
|
Rationale
Note how the early
stages attempt to nail the reason for the
initiative, and then to find out where the most
telling problems reside. Which pieces of equipment?
What parts of the body? Which employees? Rely upon
data for this.
While you want the
opinions of the people doing the work on how they
see it, what the causes of unsafe situations are,
what they'd recommend to the organization, there is
no need for them to detail the nature of the
problem. You can get that information from
insurance claims, accident reports and regulatory
documents.
The literature might
be fruitful here. You're not seeking generic
information about safety, but rather focusing on
promising approaches to prevention in a
manufacturing setting.
Questions for
Performance Problems
Here are some
questions for the sponsor or customer that are
useful when looking to solve a generic performance
problem. Print the whole page OR copy and paste the
relevant questions into a document, then save it to
your desktop or hard drive. Be sure to review the options and select and edit
to work with your source.
- Why have you
decided to attempt to deal with this problem
now?
- What are the
most critical aspects of this
problem?
- Do you have a
clear statement of what's supposed to be
happening? Is there a policy to which we may
refer?
Is the statement of the way it ought to be
up-to-date?
- Why do you
think that past fixes haven't
worked?
- If a
supervisor wants to do a bang-up job, to what
references and materials can she
turn?
- Let's look at
the primary problems you've mentioned. What will
it take to fix each of them?
- What are the
managers' and supervisors' perspectives on this
topic?
What would job incumbents say we should do to
solve the problem?
- If you could
wave a magic wand on this one, what would you
do?
- What can I
read to help me understand this topic? How can I
see into it with more depth?
What can I read? To whom should I
speak?
- Do we have
employees or sites that lack the problem? If so,
what do you think is responsible for their
success?
- What will it
take to successfully move your people this
way?
- Where might
resistance to this initiative reside? How might
we address it?
|